Sometimes the most memorable birding experiences aren’t the ones we set out to find.
An Unusual Autumn in the Central Valley
Something unusual has been happening in California’s Central Valley this autumn. Birds normally associated with the mountains and northern forests have been appearing in places where they are seldom encountered, sometimes in surprising numbers.
Clark’s Nutcrackers, Evening Grosbeaks, Red Crossbills, Cassin’s Finches, and Red-breasted Nuthatches have all been part of the excitement. For birders, these movements offer opportunities to encounter species that might otherwise require a trip into the Sierra Nevada or farther north.
Evening Grosbeaks have been reported in Merced, Stanislaus, and San Joaquin counties. I managed to obtain some less-than-spectacular but perfectly acceptable documentation photographs of a few. A female Cassin’s Finch even spent a couple of days visiting the Manteca backyard of my friends Mark and Lorna Elness.
But one species in particular had captured my attention: the Red Crossbill.
The Crossbill Chase
On October 30, local birder David Yee reported several Red Crossbills flying around the baseball complex at Louis Park in Stockton. Red Crossbills are unusual enough in San Joaquin County that I was eager to add one to my county life list.

On November 2, my friend Jim Ross and I stopped at the park to look for them. No luck.
Then, on Saturday, November 14, David reported them again, with as many as seven birds present. Kasey Foley and René Reyes also observed them that afternoon.
Naturally, Jim and I returned the following day.
Once again, the crossbills proved frustratingly elusive. Looking back, I believe I heard them calling briefly on three occasions, but the encounters were too fleeting for me to feel comfortable counting them as a new county bird.
On Monday, Kasey returned to Louis Park and reported more than 40 Red Crossbills! She also managed to photograph several, including birds perched high in the trees.

When I asked about her success, she explained, “I chose to go today because I seem to have better luck just after it rains.”
Later, when someone complimented her photographs, she modestly credited her husband, Rich: “Just luck but thanks, Rich found the group and I swung my camera around and got it.”
I couldn’t resist asking, “Is he for hire tomorrow??? 😂”
“His price is pretty steep😉” came her reply.
Well, apparently I was going to have to find my own crossbills.
On Tuesday morning, November 17, Jim and I returned to Louis Park for our third attempt.
For about 90 minutes, we alternated between watching the trees near the corner parking lot, where most sightings had occurred, and making short drives around the park.
At one point, we walked into the middle of the baseball complex. As we headed back toward the parking lot, I suddenly heard the unmistakable yip-yip, yip-yip calls of Red Crossbills.
A small flock was flying westward along Monte Diablo Road!
I had been running Merlin Sound ID, and although the app didn’t identify the crossbills, the recording captured approximately 25 seconds of their calls. After some considerable effort trimming the original ten-minute recording, I sent the relevant portion to David Yee, who agreed that the calls sounded like those of Type 2 Red Crossbills.
Finally, I had documented Red Crossbills in San Joaquin County!
I added the recording to my eBird checklist and hoped that another visit might eventually provide an opportunity for photographs.
But as satisfying as that moment was, it wasn’t going to be the highlight of the morning.
An Unexpected Gathering
Red-breasted Nuthatches are among my favorite little woodland birds. Their distinctive nasal yank-yank-yank calls frequently announce their presence long before they come into view.
Although they occur in the Central Valley during winter, my encounters have generally involved solitary birds or occasionally pairs. During years when they move into the Valley in greater numbers, they can become more widespread, but finding several together at one location has been unusual in my experience.
I had encountered my first Red-breasted Nuthatches of this season at Lodi Lake on August 25, around the time the autumn movement was becoming apparent. Since then, I had found them at several other locations around San Joaquin County, usually just one or two at a time.

On our November 15 visit to Louis Park, I heard two calling near the corner parking lot.
But November 17 was going to be different.
As Jim and I watched the nuthatches working their way through the row of pine trees, I began to suspect that there were more birds present than I could easily account for.
They were constantly moving, climbing trunks, darting between branches, and occasionally dropping toward the ground. With so much activity, it was difficult to determine whether we were repeatedly seeing the same individuals or encountering different birds.
Then something remarkable happened.
We were watching two Red-breasted Nuthatches on a tree trunk when another pair appeared on the same tree. Almost immediately, two more landed on a neighboring pine.
Six Red-breasted Nuthatches, all visible at the same time!
And farther along the row of trees, at least one more was calling.
Now I knew we were witnessing something unusual.
In all my years of birding the Central Valley, I couldn’t recall another occasion when I had encountered so many Red-breasted Nuthatches together in such a small area.
And the show was just beginning.

A Front-Row Seat
For the better part of an hour, the nuthatches entertained us with their seemingly endless activity.
They moved up and down the pine trunks, investigated crevices in the bark, chased or followed one another through the branches, and repeatedly descended to the ground.
Several appeared to be searching through the fallen needles and leaf litter for food. At least one emerged carrying what looked like a pine seed in its bill.

I watched them move between the trees, occasionally pausing just long enough for a photograph before darting off again.
At times, they approached the very tree beside which I was standing, coming within perhaps four feet of me!
Their rusty underparts, bold black-and-white facial patterns, and slate-blue backs were beautifully illuminated by the morning light. And their inquisitive, energetic behavior made them irresistible photographic subjects.
I took photograph after photograph, sometimes barely knowing which bird to follow next.
There was something wonderfully entertaining about watching these little birds go about their business, apparently unconcerned by our presence.
Were some of them chasing one another? Were they competing for food or simply following the same opportunities? I couldn’t say for certain. But the constant movement, calling, and interactions made the experience feel almost like watching a little woodland community in action.
And all of this was happening in an ordinary city park, surrounded by baseball diamonds, parking lots, and neighborhood streets.

The Birds I Wasn’t Looking For
We had come to Louis Park hoping to find Red Crossbills. After three visits, we finally succeeded, and I came away with an audio recording documenting a new bird for my San Joaquin County life list.
But it wasn’t the crossbills that kept us entertained for nearly an hour.
It was a remarkable gathering of Red-breasted Nuthatches, busily exploring the pines, searching for food, and occasionally approaching so closely that I could hardly believe my good fortune.
The crossbills were the birds I had been looking for.
The nuthatches were the birds I hadn’t expected.
And sometimes, those unexpected encounters become the memories that stay with us the longest.

Leave a Reply